
Article reviewed:
Yesil, B (2003) Internet Café as Battlefield: State Control over Internet Cafés in Turkey and the Lack of Popular Resistance, The Journal of Popular Culture, v. 37 Issue 1, Pages 120 – 127
This article is an interesting one because it talks about internet censorship that people in developed country normally do not have experience. However, in those developing countries, for various reasons, it is common to see internet censorship by government or religious leadership. In addition, how people react to this kind of control by state government also varies in different countries.
In the age of globalization, the whole world is just like a small village through modern telecommunication technology and internet. In other words, we are in an age of information sharing. As a result, popular culture also can not be treated as just a local issue. Taking advantage of modern technology, everyone no matter where he or she lives can watch foreign movies or enjoy music from another country once it is released to market. However, because people live in different countries where political, economic and religious backgrounds are different from each other; different states are treating popular culture according to their own principles.
In this article, the author examines what happens in Turkey when internet is popular and becomes a part of popular culture. The author notices that the government and religious leaders do not like internet because they believe internet is not spreading useful information and is against their traditional moral standards. On the other hand, those business owners are strongly against government’s ban to internet café. Interestingly, those common people who are internet users are not against government’s policy against internet café. For some who have lost easy access to internet café, they still think government is doing something right.
What this article describes actually is a scenario of the rising of nationalism in Turkey where government and religious leaders are trying to resist cultural influence from western countries, especially western popular culture imported from internet. Normally, this kind of nationalism is always strongly against western world and treated anything from western world as evil.
It is true that internet also comes with some contents that are not proper. However, nobody can deny how much internet has contributed to this world. Therefore, it is necessary to identify what is major contribution and what is just a minor. What happened in Turkey actually also can be found in other countries such as China. China has the largest internet user population in the world. However, to a considerable extent, internet in China is isolated from world internet because of strict censorship.
Popular culture is not treated the same way in different countries because of cultural conflicts, especially in countries where traditional religious leaders have strong influence over state government and society. Therefore, a popular cultural phenomenon like internet can be a part of usual life in some countries while it is partially or completely banned in other countries. From the perspective of popular culture analysis, it is necessary to realize that geography matters a lot.
References:
Deibert, R (2006) The geopolitics of Asian cyberspace, Far Eastern Economic Review, Vol.169 Issue10 Page: 22 - 25
Weatherby, JN et al. (2005) The other World, Pearson Longman








